The Haunted Commander’s Quarters at Letterkenny Army Depot
A centuries-old Franklin County house, two conflicting construction dates, stories from former commanders and a paranormal investigation — all with an unusual paper trail.
There are plenty of ghost stories around Franklin County. This one comes with an unusual paper trail.
At Letterkenny Army Depot stands the historic James Finley House, long known as the Commander’s Quarters. Federal Historic American Engineering Record documentation dates the house to about 1778, while a 2021 U.S. Army feature about tours of the property gives its construction date as approximately 1790.
That disagreement matters. If the earlier date is correct, the house was already standing when Franklin County was created in 1784. If the later Army date is correct, it came a few years afterward.
Either way, the house predates the creation of Letterkenny Army Depot by well over a century.
It also has another reputation.
A House With Two Dates
The James Finley House is a historic limestone-and-brick farmhouse with roots stretching back more than two centuries.
The Historic American Engineering Record, a National Park Service program whose records are held by the Library of Congress, identifies the house as the oldest known building on Letterkenny Army Depot and dates it to about 1778.
The same report also calls it one of the oldest surviving dwellings in Franklin County.
That wording matters. “Oldest known” is not the same thing as definitively oldest. The HAER notes that several other farmhouses on the depot had not been accurately dated, with construction estimates ranging from the late 18th century into the early 20th century.
The paper trail for 1778 is documented, but not especially deep. The HAER’s own notes point back to earlier National Register material, along with an undated Letterkenny history of the commanding officer’s residence.
A 2021 Army article, however, dates construction to approximately 1790.
Because that is what the sources actually say. Franklin County Life found no reason to quietly choose one date and ignore the other.
What is not in dispute is that the house stood long before Letterkenny Army Depot was established in 1942.
The property was acquired for use as the commanding officer’s residence after the depot was created. A 2021 Army feature says the house no longer serves as the commander’s residence and instead contains historical exhibits and is used for tours and events.
In 2024, the Army again described the Finley House as a location for commander socials and public events.
And somewhere along the way, the old house accumulated stories.
“Be Careful. The House Is Haunted.”
In the Army’s 2024 account, one former commander recalled being warned on the day he moved in that the house was haunted.
He initially brushed it off.
That night, according to the commander, his wife saw the figure of an older woman with her hair tied back. She described the figure as having no visible legs.
Oddly, she did not describe the encounter as frightening. She told her husband that she felt at peace.
About a year later, the family hosted friends for Christmas Eve dinner.
Before the commander could begin giving them a tour, one friend entered the family room alone and quickly returned pale and trembling.
He said he had seen a ghost.
The commander later emphasized that the guests had never been told about the house’s haunted reputation.
That friend apparently never returned.
The Woman in the Kitchen
Another former commander told the Army that stories about the house were already common among Letterkenny employees and people in the surrounding community.
One incident involved a senior depot employee helping with a social event.
After the guests had left, the employee returned to the darkened kitchen to begin cleaning.
Before turning on the lights, he said he saw the silhouette of a woman in a dress who appeared to already be cleaning.
She did not speak.
Other residents described similar sightings of a female figure in the kitchen, along with nighttime noises and kitchen items being moved.
The former commander also recalled that the house once had maid’s quarters directly above the kitchen.
That detail eventually became part of the legend, with some residents associating the mysterious woman with a former servant.
There is no historical evidence establishing that interpretation. But the story endured.

The Paranormal Investigation
In 2021, a paranormal group called The Ghost Pit investigated the Finley House with former Letterkenny employees.
According to the Army’s account, investigators said they recorded figures using a structured-light sensor camera and voices through a device commonly called a spirit box.
In an upstairs bathroom, investigators interpreted one image as resembling a young girl pointing toward a doorway. Elsewhere, they reported another fleeting figure.
During one session, an overhead light appeared to flicker after investigators asked an unseen presence to interact with it.
The group also reported hearing what sounded like a young girl humming outside a room.
At another point, investigators interpreted a voice coming through the spirit-box equipment as saying “wait” twice while a former employee was leaving.
Why Old Houses Collect Stories
Devices used in paranormal investigations can produce ambiguous sounds and images, and old houses provide plenty of ordinary sources for creaks, drafts, shadows and movement.
Expectation matters too. Once people know a place has a haunted reputation, ordinary sights and sounds can take on a different meaning.
A house that has stood for more than two centuries has produced countless ordinary noises, shadows and unexplained moments.
Wood shifts. Stone walls hold cold air. Old floors creak. Light changes strangely through older windows.
Human memory does something else: stories get shared.
One resident tells another. Employees hear what previous employees experienced. A visitor walks into a room already carrying expectations formed by decades of local lore.
Sometimes that explains a ghost story. Sometimes it simply gives the story another generation.
History We Can Establish
The property is centuries old, appears in federal historic documentation, predates Letterkenny Army Depot by well over a century and served for decades as the commanding officer’s residence.
Legend We Cannot Prove
Former commanders, employees and paranormal investigators have reported unusual experiences. None of those accounts establishes that the property is actually haunted.
Is It Really Franklin County’s Oldest House?
The Army’s 2024 haunting feature calls the Finley House “the oldest house in Franklin County.”
Franklin County Life is treating that as the Army’s characterization, not a settled countywide ranking.
The Army-commissioned HAER survey itself uses more cautious language. It identifies the Finley House as the oldest known building on Letterkenny Army Depot and describes it as one of the oldest surviving dwellings in Franklin County.
Other historic Franklin County houses also date to the 18th century, including the Col. John Work House near Mercersburg, generally dated to about 1775.
If the Army’s later 1790 construction date for the Finley House is correct, the countywide “oldest house” claim becomes even harder to sustain.
None of that diminishes the Finley House’s significance. It simply illustrates why old-house history sometimes requires careful wording.
History Where We Can Prove It. Legend Where We Can’t.
The James Finley House is a centuries-old Franklin County property now inside Letterkenny Army Depot. Federal HAER documentation dates it to about 1778, while a later Army article gives an approximate date of 1790.
Former commanders and employees really did tell the Army about unusual experiences inside it, and paranormal investigators really did visit the property looking for answers.
What none of those sources can establish is whether anyone encountered a ghost.
That remains part of the legend.
The James Finley House still stands at Letterkenny Army Depot, carrying more than two centuries of documented history — along with stories that refuse to disappear.
And if the old accounts are to be believed, some former occupants may have been reluctant to leave.
Sources & Reporting Notes
Read the Army article →
Read the 2021 Army article →
View the HAER documentation →
View the National Register record →
